Does Nutella Go Bad?

So there’s this jar of Nutella that’s sitting in the cabinet in the kitchen. It’s been there for quite some time already. At this point, you start to question whether it’s still okay to use. Does Nutella go bad? Sandwich spreads usually last quite some time, but seeing milk on the ingredients list might make you think it’s going bad pretty quick. If you would like to learn a bit more about storage, shelf life, and going bad of this popular spread, read on.

Nutella Art
(credit: Etereal9)

How to Store Nutella

You should store Nutella jars similarly to other sandwich spreads, such as peanut butter. That means the jar should sit a cool and dark place, away from any sources of heat and sunlight. The temperature between 18°C (or 64°F) and 20°C (or 68°F) is perfect for the spread. That means the pantry or a cabinet in the kitchen is the place to go.

Once you open the jar, the storage guidelines stay the same. Obviously, the jar should be sealed tightly when not in use. There’s no need for refrigerating Nutella. Quite on the contrary, chilling it will harden the product and make it difficult to spread. If Nutella is stiff, you can try melting it in the microwave.

Last but not least, practicing proper hygiene will help Nutella retain its quality for longer. For Nutella, and other spreads, adequate hygiene means you should always use a clean spoon or knife when scooping the spread. Yeah, using your fingers might be more fun for some of you, but that’s definitely not the way to go. Using your fingers or utensils, you already used for other purposes will likely transfer bacteria or contaminants to the hazelnut spread. And those contaminants might contribute to the product going bad or degrading in quality.

How Long Does Nutella Last

There’s usually a best-by date on a jar of Nutella. That date is a rough estimate for how long the product should retain its freshness. Of course, the spread will be safe to eat for much longer, but its quality will degrade over time. As usual, there’s no good way of determining for how long past the best-by date Nutella will be good enough for eating in terms of quality.

When it comes to an opened jar of Nutella, it easily lasts for at least a few months. Ferrero’s website informs that the spread lasts 12 months after opening. Of course, as mentioned earlier, the spread loses its freshness over time so Nutella that’s sitting in the kitchen for 6 months won’t be as good as a freshly opened one.

Pantry
Nutella (unopened)Best By + 6 months
Nutella (opened)6 months

How to Tell If Nutella Is Bad

Nutella contains a good amount of oil. That means it’s susceptible to going rancid. If the spread smells rancid or somewhat odd, toss it out. Rancid oils aren’t necessarily unsafe to eat, but they definitely don’t smell and taste good. The presence of oil in Nutella also means that some of it might separate on top after storing the spread for a long time. It’s a natural occurrence. The same thing happens in other products like peanut butter, tahini, or mustard. If that happens, you can simply stir the product to get it back in shape.

As already mentioned, Nutella degrades in quality over time. When you first open the jar, the texture is creamy and soft. Over time it starts to harden and dry out. It’s an ongoing process, so it’s not like one day it’s perfectly creamy and the next day it’s rock solid. At a certain point, the spread will become difficult to use, and that’s when it’s time to discard it. Nutella also loses its flavor over time, so if it no longer quite hits the spot, it’s time to open a new jar.

As usual, you should look out for the classic signs of spoilage like any signs of bacterial growth or mold, foul or funny odor, and noticeable changes in texture. If Nutella looks and smells okay, you can taste a bit to determine if it’s still good enough to use. Decide whether to keep it or throw it out based on how it tastes.

Last but not least, if the jar of Nutella is open for a very long time, like 2+ years, it’s better to discard it for safety reasons. It might seem to be perfectly fine, but there’s no reason to risk it.

6 thoughts on “Does Nutella Go Bad?”

  1. This is my rock bottom.
    I hope I don’t get food poisoning and die.
    If I do, at least I won’t have to live with the shame of eating year-old nutella.

  2. I have had a jar of “bad” nutella for a bit over a year and the only difference is that it has a stronger hazelnut taste, so yeah.

  3. Last year for Christmas my mother had bought me a Nutella to go. She had forgotten to put it in my stocking,so this year when the time came around and she found it, she just threw it in there again. She told me the story but I ate it anyways:-)

  4. Well the Nutella I found in my girlfriends house had a sell by date of two years ago and I’m still eating it whatever idc it doesn’t look or smell bad and taste kinda good.

  5. The Nutella I’m currently trying to eat had it’s sell by date April of last year and it still smells good and now have tasted it still tastes like Nutella but the taste is a little dulled down so yeah year old already opened Nutella still tastes pretty decent.

  6. I just finished a jar of nutella that was 2 years and 7 months past the expired date. Is that a new record? It was opened and half eaten before that too. I estimate it’s at least 3.5 years since it was opened. When I found it again recently and started eating it it was hard and tiny, slightly lighter coloured bumps all over it. Once I stirred it round it became creamy again. Every now and again I find a little hard piece in my mouth. I’ve been having bad gas since I started eating it but that could be unrelated. I’m probably an idiot… oh well I won’t die haha… 😐

Comments are closed.